Eclipse happened because of Rahu?

[Indra]

komentar Bhikkhu Bodhi (dalam footnote SN):

Candima is a deva dwelling in the mansion of the moon. Suriya ia deva dwelling in the mansion of the sun.

When Rahu sees the sun and moon shining brightly, he becomes jealous and enters their orbital paths, where he stands with mouth agape. It then seems as if the lunar and solar mansions have been plunged into the great hell, and the devas in those mansions all cry out simultaneously in terror. While Rahu can cover the mansions with his hand, jaw, and tongue, and can even stuff his cheeks with them, he is unable to obstruct their motion. If he did make such an attempt they would split his head and come through the other side or pull him along and push him down [Spk-pt: because their motion is determined by the law of kamma and is extremely hard for anyone to stop directly].

[Edward]

Mo tanya, gerhana itu kejadian yang berulang2 setiap tahun, bearti kejadian yang disebutkan juga terjadi saat ini?

[El Sol]

komentar Bhikkhu Bodhi (dalam footnote SN):

Candima is a deva dwelling in the mansion of the moon. Suriya ia deva dwelling in the mansion of the sun.

When Rahu sees the sun and moon shining brightly, he becomes jealous and enters their orbital paths, where he stands with mouth agape. It then seems as if the lunar and solar mansions have been plunged into the great hell, and the devas in those mansions all cry out simultaneously in terror. While Rahu can cover the mansions with his hand, jaw, and tongue, and can even stuff his cheeks with them, he is unable to obstruct their motion. If he did make such an attempt they would split his head and come through the other side or pull him along and push him down [Spk-pt: because their motion is determined by the law of kamma and is extremely hard for anyone to stop directly].

maksud aye itu...

gerhana matahari terjadi karena...

matahari dihalangi oleh bulan, sehingga bayangan kena bumi, dan terjadilah gerhana matahari, dari Bumi emank keliatan kayak dimakan...tapi asline bukan..

kalo gerhana bulan terjadi karena...

matahari bersejajar dengan bumi dan bulan, sehingga banyangan bumi kena bulan...

so, ke-2 gerhana itu jelas banget BUKAN gara2 DEWA ato ASHURA...

[El Sol]

Mo tanya, gerhana itu kejadian yang berulang2 setiap tahun, bearti kejadian yang disebutkan juga terjadi saat ini?

nice question!

[El Sol]

ini thread senjata bagus buat yg non-Buddhist neh..

cape deh kalo ada error yg gitu parah di Buddhism...

jangan2 Nibbana itu juga cuma imajinasi?...

karena sampe skarang, di ke-3 aliran, Nibbana itu definisinya juga beda2...

[Indra]

kalo yg gue tangkap dari komentar itu, "walaupun Rahu mampu menelan matahari dan bulan, ia tidak mampu menghentikan rotasinya" artinya gerhana bukan karena Rahu

[El Sol]

kalo yg gue tangkap dari komentar itu, "walaupun Rahu mampu menelan matahari dan bulan, ia tidak mampu menghentikan rotasinya" artinya gerhana bukan karena Rahu

itu jelas banget ko artinya....

kalo Rahu bisa buat Gerhana tapi gk bisa selama2nya...

dia nelan bulan dan matahari, tapi cuma bentar...

nah, pertanyaannya itu...

apakah gerhana terjadi gara2 ditelan Rahu?

[Edward]

klo menurut gw, soal nibbana mah, ketiga aliran inti-nya setuju dengan "antara ada dan tiada, kebahagiaan tertinggi" .

[El Sol]

klo menurut gw, soal nibbana mah, ketiga aliran inti-nya setuju dengan "antara ada dan tiada, kebahagiaan tertinggi" .

which is something that is scientifically unproven and logically unthinkable...

Nibbana itu terlalu vague, sampe gw sempet ngerasa kalo itu gk exist..

sebuah teori yg tidak bisa dibuktikan..

Bukti idup(ato mati) Nibbana cuma sang Buddha...well, he's gone now, and we'll never know that he really attained Nibbana or not..darou?

[El Sol]

Well, gw gk mencoba meng-convert kalian jadi Atheist..karena gw sendiri masih Buddhist..

but then....makin belajar, makin banyak pertanyaan..

[Indra]

kalo yg gue tangkap dari komentar itu, "walaupun Rahu mampu menelan matahari dan bulan, ia tidak mampu menghentikan rotasinya" artinya gerhana bukan karena Rahu

itu jelas banget ko artinya....

kalo Rahu bisa buat Gerhana tapi gk bisa selama2nya...

dia nelan bulan dan matahari, tapi cuma bentar...

nah, pertanyaannya itu...

apakah gerhana terjadi gara2 ditelan Rahu?

dilanjutkan: Jika Rahu melakukan itu (menelan) maka kepalanya akan pecah dan akan menariknya. jadi di sini Rahu pasti mati karena kepalanya pecah. jadi kesimpulan Rahu gak menelan matahari dan bulan

[Edward]

di Thailand sono katanya bertebaran yang dikatakan udh jadi arhat...
Bukannya arhat sudah mencapai nibbana?

[Edward]

Makssudnya om, memank tidak bisa menelan, tapi ada kejadian "gelap sesaat". sama seperti gerhana, hanya proses "gelap sesaat", dan ketika bulan ato matahari berevolusi kembali, jadilah terang..

[fabian c]

Teman-teman, terus terang mengenai Rahu ini memang meragukan tapi saya rasa dalam kasus ini mirip raja naga Nandopananda yang melilit gunung Sineru.

Dalam hal ini yang masih  belum nyambung adalah periode berkala gerhana, apakah Rahu secara berkala juga menyerang  Candima dan Suriya secara teratur?

 

[fabian c]

Well, gw gk mencoba meng-convert kalian jadi Atheist..karena gw sendiri masih Buddhist..

but then....makin belajar, makin banyak pertanyaan..

Lemparkan  ke forum bro...